< Find Similar
Is Cow's Milk Superior to Plant-Based Alternatives? Recent Studies Reveal Surprising Facts
Published:
July 28, 2023
Updated:
August 4, 2023

Is Cow's Milk Superior to Plant-Based Alternatives? Recent Studies Reveal Surprising Facts

As an Amazon Associate, Healthify earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability as of are subject to change. See full disclaimer and affiliate policy here.

As consumers continue to prioritize health and sustainability, the plant-based milk industry has been expanding at an unprecedented rate. A walk down the grocery store aisle will introduce you to a gamut of choices, from familiar options like almond milk and oat milk, to more recent additions such as pistachio milk and cashew milk.

Plant Based Milk Products

However, recent research sheds light on the nutritional variance between cow's milk and these burgeoning alternatives. The findings may cause you to re-evaluate your milk preferences.

According to studies presented at the American Society for Nutrition's Nutrition 2023 annual conference, led by researchers from the University of Minnesota, most plant-based milk alternatives fall short when compared to cow's milk in terms of nutrient content.

The research examined the nutritional profiles of 237 milk substitutes, including almond, rice, oat, pea, and soy milks.

The results revealed that merely 12% of these plant-based products offered amounts of calcium, vitamin D, and protein equivalent to or exceeding those found in cow's milk.

The lion's share of plant-based milks examined in the study were derived from almonds, oats, or soy. While 170 of these products were fortified with both calcium and vitamin D, achieving levels comparable to cow's milk, a mere 16% had protein levels that matched or exceeded the 8 grams per 240 milliliters present in cow's milk. It's noteworthy that soy and pea milks were the likeliest candidates to harbor higher protein levels.

While these revelations may come as a surprise, experts in nutrition express little astonishment. Gina Keatley, a nutritionist and co-owner of Keatley Medical Nutrition Therapy, emphasized that "plant-based milks struggle to be as nutritious as animal milk." It's crucial to recognize these beverages' limitations while incorporating them into our diets.

The Little Book of Game Changers

Plant-based milks are often perceived as healthier alternatives due to the 'health halo' surrounding them. However, Jessica Cording, a registered dietitian and author of The Little Book of Game-Changers, cautions that these milks do not possess the same nutrient profiles that one might expect from dairy milk.

They often contain additional ingredients to mimic the taste and texture of cow's milk.

Furthermore, the nutrient content in different brands of plant-based milk varies significantly, whereas cow's milk is strictly regulated, and the nutrient content remains consistent. This inconsistency in plant-based milks can lead to unpredictable nutritional results, making label-reading an essential practice for health-conscious consumers.

Despite these disparities, plant-based milks serve as valuable alternatives for those with lactose intolerance or sensitivity. Additionally, plant milks are cholesterol-free and typically low in saturated fat, which can offer health benefits for some individuals.

Nonetheless, the research underlines the importance of not assuming that all plant-based milks are nutritionally equivalent to cow's milk. While protein can be readily sourced from other elements of a balanced diet, calcium and vitamin D are primary nutrients that people seek from dairy. If these nutrients are not coming from other dietary sources, it becomes imperative to select plant-based milk products that contain these crucial ingredients.

The decision about the type of milk to include in your diet largely hinges on your nutritional needs and preferences. If you're seeking a beverage to add to your coffee, without focusing on its nutritional content or satiety level, plant-based milks may offer you greater flexibility. However, if you're hunting for a dairy substitute that offers a similar nutrient profile, then it's important to find products enriched with calcium, vitamin D, and protein.

Young Woman and Grandma Drinking Milk

Consider your overall diet and health goals when making these choices. For instance, if you're looking for a plant-based milk with nutritional value similar to cow's milk, aim for a product offering about 300 milligrams of calcium per 8-ounce serving, 100 IU of vitamin D, and 8 grams of protein. It's also wise to limit sugar intake; aim for no more than 14 grams of natural and added sugars combined.

In conclusion, while plant-based milks provide a valuable alternative for those with dietary restrictions or preferences, they are not a one-to-one replacement for cow's milk in terms of nutrition. However, by making informed choices and scrutinizing product labels, consumers can ensure they are meeting their dietary needs.

Remember to check out more news and knowledge-based articles for health and wellness inspiration on Healthify. Additionally, take advantage of the free Healthify AI chat assistant here for any questions or concerns related to the topic in the article or health and wellness advice, support, diagnosis assistance, or general knowledge, available 24/7!

Sources:

Stay in the know

Get the latest updates so you can stay healthy.

Explore More